Page 1 of 1

about the Markus ban

Posted: Fri 21 Feb , 2014 10:00 pm
by proof
How can you spawnkill on Ascend? I somehow feel like Eif just banned him because he talked German to me even though Eif didnt want it. But German is allowed.

Re: about the Markus ban

Posted: Fri 21 Feb , 2014 10:11 pm
by Azarael
> Eiforia: can u talk fucking english??

... (20 or so lines)

> }GBD{Markus@mp3: "it is not good cherry eating with me"
> }GBD{Markus@mp3: ^^
> }GBD{Markus@mp3 left the game.
> proof: was xD
> proof: did you kick markus?
> team-spec*Earl: that luck
> proof: eif?
> proof: keine antwort, ist auch ne antwort (eng: no answer is also an answer)

This is... weird to say the least.

Previous map's log doesn't show any problem (it's EMP-JolteonTrials anyway) and Markus is banned at the end of Ascend.

Re: about the Markus ban

Posted: Fri 21 Feb , 2014 10:32 pm
by Eiforia
He spawnkilled at Hellbender RACE nightmare with redeemer.
I kicked him.
And after decided tht its not fair to other players i banned today for spawnkilling, so i banned him like others.


> france: bouummm
> }GBD{Markus@mp3 left the game.

> Eiforia: kicked

> }GBD{Markus@mp3 joined as a spectator.
> }GBD{Markus@mp3: :p

> Eiforia: next time u'll be banned
> }GBD{Markus@mp3: awww

> [TmB]Happy_coucounet: for ?
> }GBD{Markus@mp3: deemerspawnkill xD

Re: about the Markus ban

Posted: Fri 21 Feb , 2014 11:10 pm
by Azarael
At the risk of receiving the obvious replies, most obviously "you're biased", "you're assuming bad faith" and "even when she bans her friends you're not happy":
  • When did we ever escalate (as opposed to lessening the effect of) previously executed admin actions, even if they were apparently demonstrating undue leniency to friends?
  • There seems to be some strong discontent at German being spoken. Why should anyone believe that he wasn't just moved up to a ban because he irritated the admin by speaking German? Shortly after the discontent with German is expressed, magically it's decided that Markus is to be banned.

Re: about the Markus ban

Posted: Fri 21 Feb , 2014 11:24 pm
by Eiforia
Idk how it depends with German language which was allowed most part of the time I play here... And its not the first time I ask them to talk English... And not because I'm admin lol, just coz I like to talk with ppl and don't understand when they are talking in language I don't understand :/

Aza unban him if you want if it makes you happy)))

Re: about the Markus ban

Posted: Fri 21 Feb , 2014 11:28 pm
by Azarael
You express frustration with him talking German and within any time from 30 seconds to a couple of minutes, a previous action against him is upgraded to a ban. I don't see how that can be interpreted as anything but spite. There's no precedent for such a thing and nobody except you and Markus knew or remembered the kick you'd given him earlier, so I don't see any reason why you'd care to upgrade his ban except as a petty way of expressing discontent with him.

I've no intention of seeing him unbanned. If he spawnkilled, 1 day is the correct punishment. I merely take issue with how this was implemented, and even if anyone tries to argue there was a good faith intention in that ban upgrade (which I doubt), there's still the question of why Markus gets a kick and two others get banned for the same offense in the same day. Markus is a persistent violator and has been around long enough to know the rules.

Re: about the Markus ban

Posted: Fri 21 Feb , 2014 11:40 pm
by Eiforia
Azarael wrote: there's still the question of why Markus gets a kick and two others get banned for the same offense in the same day.
Because I saw them already few times do the same. I warned them. Today I decided tht its enough and I banned them.
I hope I answered ya question. Since today I will write you a PM every time I do some actions against players. To not bother myself answering millions of your questions Aza.

Re: about the Markus ban

Posted: Sat 22 Feb , 2014 12:48 am
by iZumo
IMO the "ban upgrage" is a consequence of certain recent events: "kick - some time - realization he should be banned - ban".

Code: Select all

2014-02-21 19:29:04 Ban: ... }GBD{Markus@mp3 Reason: Spawnkilling ...
Not saying it happened the "best way" but I can understand it.